10 garage sale finds that have gained serious value

10 garage sale finds that have gained serious value

It's easy to walk past old dishes, furniture, or toys at a garage sale without a second thought-but some of those "random" finds are worth far more than they look. Collectors and resellers have turned everyday vintage items into serious money-makers, especially as nostalgia drives demand.

The trick is knowing what to look for-because what looks outdated to one person could be a hidden payday for someone else.

Here are ten common garage sale finds that have quietly gone up in value.

Pyrex and Fire-King dishes

Vintage Pyrex and Fire-King glassware used to sell for a few bucks, but today, rare colors and patterns can go for hundreds. Sets from the 1950s and 1960s, like Gooseberry, Snowflake, or Jadeite, are especially sought after.

Condition matters-chips and faded patterns lower the value-but complete sets or mint-condition pieces can sell fast online. If you see those bright nesting bowls or pastel casserole dishes, grab them.

Mid-century furniture

Solid wood dressers, coffee tables, and sideboards from the 1950s-1970s are worth real money now. Even if they look worn, collectors love the clean lines and craftsmanship.

Pieces from brands like Lane, Drexel, and Heywood-Wakefield can be worth hundreds or more. If it's solid wood and has tapered legs or minimal design, there's a good chance it's mid-century-and valuable.

Vintage vinyl records

Old records might look like clutter, but certain artists and pressings have become collector favorites. First editions, limited runs, and albums from iconic artists like The Beatles or Fleetwood Mac can fetch serious prices.

Even lesser-known records can surprise you-especially if they're in good condition with original sleeves. Always check labels and serial numbers before you pass up a crate of vinyl.

Cast iron cookware

Brands like Griswold, Wagner, and early Lodge skillets have gone way up in value. Collectors love the craftsmanship and smooth finish that modern cast iron doesn't have.

Rusty pieces can often be restored with a good cleaning and seasoning, which makes them an easy flip. Check the bottom for maker's marks-some rare ones can sell for hundreds.

Old advertising signs

Vintage metal or porcelain advertising signs are a favorite among collectors. Gasoline brands, soda companies, and farm equipment logos all have strong resale value.

Even signs with some wear are worth something if they're authentic. Look for signs with embossed lettering or fading that shows age-not modern reproductions made to look old.

Vintage toys

Toys from the '70s through early 2000s have become highly collectible, especially if they're complete or in their original packaging. Think Star Wars figures, Hot Wheels, Polly Pocket, or early LEGO sets.

Even used toys can bring good money if they're rare or discontinued. A bin of old action figures or dolls could end up being your best find of the day.

Typewriters

Old manual typewriters have become popular again with collectors, writers, and interior decorators. Brands like Royal, Smith-Corona, and Underwood are especially desirable.

Working models sell best, but even broken ones have value as décor pieces. If you find one in decent shape with a carrying case, it's worth a second look.

Cameras and film gear

Vintage cameras, especially 35mm models from Canon, Nikon, or Pentax, are in high demand. Film photography made a comeback, and people want the real deal.

Even older Polaroid cameras have resale value, especially the SX-70 and 600 models. Garage sales are one of the best places to find them cheap before they get resold online for much more.

Costume jewelry

What used to be considered "cheap" jewelry is now collectible, especially pieces from brands like Trifari, Coro, or Monet. Vintage costume jewelry can bring in serious money if it's in good condition.

Look for quality materials-heavy metal settings, real stones, or intricate designs. Even unsigned pieces can surprise you once you learn what to spot.

Board games and puzzles

Older board games from the '60s through '90s can bring in more than you'd expect, especially if they're complete. Original versions of games like Monopoly, Clue, or Mouse Trap can be worth money to collectors.

Even 2000s nostalgia games like Mall Madness or Dream Phone are seeing higher resale prices. Always check for all the pieces, because complete sets sell best.

*This article was developed with AI-powered tools and has been carefully reviewed by our editors.